Survey Says...


Due to previous commitments I had to squeeze in an analysis of the results from my recent Nikon DSLR survey at the point where we had about 4000 Nikon DSLR user responses (in less than 48 hours). With publication of this article, the survey will now be closed to further entries. 

Be prepared for some surprises. Okay, maybe those of you who’ve been paying close attention to my postings both here and on various Internet fora might not be quite so surprised. Still, one of my primary calls to Nikon was pretty much verified by this poll: produce the D300s replacement, ASAP. 

As you may recall, many people who got Nikon’s original poll interpreted that survey as trying to figure out which FX camera they would upgrade to. Surprise, surprise, DX ain’t dead yet Nikon, even though someone in Tokyo seems to be giving it short shrift.

Let’s talk about which current DSLR cameras the 4000 survey takers owned, as it’s actually important to the point I’m going to make: 26.1% reported a D800, D800E, or D810 as their primary camera, by far the biggest concentration. D7000, D7100, and D7200 owners made up the second biggest grouping at 20.2%. Since I already mentioned a D300s replacement, the D200, D300, D300s crowd made up 10.9% of the primary camera choices. Before we go any further, ask yourself an important question: which camera do you think all these folk want to upgrade to or supplement their current DSLR with? 

I’m going to jump to the other end of the survey and report the type of photography people reported practicing, as it might impact the way you interpret the results (or might not ;~). Given that I’m mostly known as a nature photographer, you’d expect those related categories to be high in the list, and they are. Here are the categories in which a quarter or more of the takers said they partake. 

  • Landscape 72.13%
  • Nature 52%
  • Travel (vacation) 48.8%
  • Scenic 46.5%
  • Travel (hiking) 40.7%
  • Travel (city) 39.2%
  • Portrait 37.7%
  • Wildlife 34.1%
  • Children 29%
  • Macro (plants) 27%
  • Street 26.1%
  • Event 25.9%

Again, balance that against the cameras that were primary cameras. Does this match your expectations?

A number of photographic subjects fell just below my one-quarter requirement to report specific percentages: Sports (field), Night, Bird, Architecture, and Black and white would be the next five categories, all near the 20% mark.

98% of you are men, and the age demographics skew towards the high end, with very few answering the survey being 34 or younger:

bythom nikon poll age

So what about cameras, you ask? What camera did all these folk want?

I asked three basic purchase questions: (1) what of Nikon’s current models would you upgrade to in the coming year; (2) what new camera I defined would you upgrade to; and (3) what new camera I defined would you supplement your current primary camera with.

60.7% of you are not likely to upgrade your current Nikon DSLR to another of the current models in the coming year. Those of you who did consider updating said: D810/D810a (13.5%), D750 (11.5%), and D7200 (9.7%). Nothing else was close or even made it to the 2% level. 

Once I defined some new possible Nikon cameras to upgrade to, suddenly about half of those who weren’t going to upgrade to an existing camera now wanted to upgrade. (For the statisticians amongst you, I made a mistake in the wording of this question that makes it impossible to make a perfect conclusion between the two questions. But I was trying to keep my questions as close to Nikon’s as possible.)

But guess what your choice was? Basically a D300s followup. 25.3% of the survey respondents, by far the biggest percentage, would opt for some form of D300s followup as an upgrade to their primary camera. The next biggest response was a D810 followup with a 54mp sensor (at 13%). I’m going to reproduce the full list here:

bythom nikon upgrade

Note that the mirrorless options I gave all tended to be relatively low in takers.

What if the new camera purchased was to supplement the current camera? A fascinating answer, actually. 23.8% still wanted one of the D300s followups I mentioned. The 54mp D810 followup slipped to 5.4%, and the 24mp FX mirrorless entry suddenly eclipsed that (at 10.5%). 

bythom nikon supplement

Okay. But one nice thing about running SurveyMonkey is that I can perform cross tabs very easily. Let’s just look at D800, D800E, and D810 owners for a moment. I was actually curious to see where they came from:

  • 19.3% came from a Nikon film SLR
  • 10.1% came from other film SLRs


Note: I debated about whether to make this question restrictive to one camera (in which case the totals would come to 100%) or allow multiple answers. In the end I chose the latter because previous surveys from my site show large quantities of multiple body ownership. I wanted to see what these bodies were prior to owning their current primary camera.

  • 6.5% came from other brand DSLRs (so there you have a switcher percentage you can chew on)

But what about previous Nikon DSLRs they might have upgraded from?

  • 16.5% came from a D800/D800E (that means they bought a D810, which explains all the used D800’s on the market)
  • 19.5% came from a D70
  • 41.6% came from a D300 or D300s
  • 14.5% came from a D7000, another 6.5% from the D7100

Now isn’t that fascinating? What do these D800/D810 users want next?

  • 15.2% of the group still are thinking about upgrading from D800 to D810. 

Given all that D800 to D810 upgrading going on and still happening in the future, you’d expect my 54mp D900 upgrade offering to be what they’d move to next. Sure enough 30.6% would upgrade to it. The next highest percentage was 6.8% for a 24mp FX mirrorless camera that used the F-mount.

But here’s where things get fascinating: 29.1% would supplement their D800/D800E/D810 with a D300s followup. You read that right, about as many D8xx users would opt to add a high-end DX body to their current camera as would upgrade their current camera to more megapixels. So surely I’d see a change in percentages of types of photography these folks do, right? Not so much. They’re even more Landscape oriented than the overall group (now up to 80.1%), though both Wildlife and Birds showed increases over the average DSLR user surveyed (Birds now over the one-quarter mark). The Travel categories slid down a bit.

Likewise I decided to look at just the D300 and D300s primary users and see how they responded. They came from one of the following, primarily:

  • 38.7% reported they came from D70
  • 21.7% came from D200
  • 25.5% came from Nikon film SLR
  • 17.3% came from Compact camera that wasn’t Nikon (6.5% from Coolpix)
  • 12.3% came from Film SLR that wasn’t Nikon
  • 5% came from another vendor’s DSLR (again, a switch metric to consider)

You might be able to discern from that just how seminal the D300 was to Nikon: yes, it moved one of its most successful previous DSLR customer bases (D70) to a better camera. Yes, it moved the previous camera base upward (D200). But look at those other big numbers. The D300 pulled in a lot of lingering film users as well as some new-to-Nikon folk who weren’t yet using DSLRs but were using digital cameras of some sort.

If the D300 user was going to upgrade in the next 12 months, they’d get a D7200 (10.3%) or D810 (11.2%), or a D750 (10%). That’s about it. Give them a D300s replacement and 72.5% would upgrade. But more interestingly, 25.3% would supplement their current D300 with the replacement (I read that as they’d own both). Add those together and yes, we’re near 100%. A D300s replacement is as no-brainer as anything else Nikon could do tomorrow. 

In terms of the types of photography this group does, I did note that Field sports jumped up to 18.7% and Wildlife shot up to 39.4%. Birds also jumped up to 27.4%. So there’s obviously some that are still using the D300 (and want a replacement) for things that need more frames per second, autofocus, and high ISO performance. 

I’m not going to go further in analyzing the survey publicly. It does suggest that for the typical readers of this site—who tend to be serious photographers—Nikon’s big options are to entice current Nikon DSLRs users to upgrade to a 24mp DX pro performance camera that replaces the D300s, plus a 54mp FX upgrade to the D810. So judge what Nikon launches (other than the D5) by that filter. And since I just mentioned the D5, there’s definitely a smallish group that wants that camera (mostly currently D3 to D4s owners), and there’s an equal sized group that wants a D5x version. 

So, bottom line: if Nikon wants to shore up their high end: D400, D950, D5, D5x. That’ll do it. 

To Nikon: if a Japanese Nikon executive is reading this and wishes access to the full survey data, I’d be happy to supply it, as I’ve done with some previous surveys. All it takes is to contact me directly.

Looking for gear-specific information? Check out our other Web sites:
mirrorless: | general:| Z System: | film SLR:

dslrbodies: all text and original images © 2022 Thom Hogan
portions Copyright 1999-2021 Thom Hogan—All Rights Reserved